MMORPGs Tier List: Every Major MMO Ranked
Twenty-three worlds, thousands of hours of grinding, and a lot of strong opinions. We pulled together what fans and critics actually say across forums, reviews and years of discourse to rank the MMORPGs that mattered (and a few that still do).
This covers the genre's biggest names, the cult favorites that refuse to die, and a couple of cautionary tales. Some of these you've sunk years into. Some you tried once during a free trial weekend and never opened again. Disagree with where we put yours? That's half the fun of a list like this. Make your own.
The tier list
The community’s tier list fills in as members vote. It appears once 5 members have ranked or voted on these.
Think you can rank them better?
Make your own tier listFree account. Your ranking stays private unless you share it, and it counts toward the community tier list.Vote
SS Tier: The genre-definers
World of Warcraft
Still the reference point every other MMO gets measured against, for better or worse. Raiding guilds, server communities, the Dark Portal, two decades of expansions, love it or hate it, you can't talk about this genre without starting here.
About World of Warcraft
Blizzard's fantasy MMO set in the Warcraft universe, running continuously since its 2004 launch. Known for its raid content, expansion cycle, and massive cultural footprint.
- Released
- 2004
- Developer
- Blizzard Entertainment
Final Fantasy XIV
Went from a notorious launch disaster to arguably the best-written MMO ever made. The Shadowbringers story alone converted a generation of players who swore they hated MMOs, and the job system design is endlessly copied.
About Final Fantasy XIV
A Square Enix MMO that relaunched in 2013 as A Realm Reborn after its disastrous original 2010 version. Praised for its story-driven expansions like Heavensward and Shadowbringers.
- Relaunched
- 2013
- Developer
- Square Enix
Old School RuneScape
A 2007 snapshot of RuneScape that somehow became one of the most actively updated games in the genre, with players voting on content through in-game polls. The grind is the point, and millions of people are still fine with that.
About Old School RuneScape
A 2013 revival of RuneScape's 2007 version, maintained alongside the main game with content driven heavily by player polls.
- Released
- 2013
- Developer
- Jagex
AA Tier: Excellent, no real asterisks
Guild Wars 2
No subscription, no trinity-locked combat, and dynamic events that actually pull strangers together instead of making them queue separately. The living world story model has its detractors, but the core gameplay still feels fresh years later.
About Guild Wars 2
ArenaNet's buy-to-play MMO known for its dynamic event system and action-oriented combat without a dedicated healer role.
- Released
- 2012
- Developer
- ArenaNet
EverQuest
The game that proved 3D persistent worlds could work at scale, and the one that invented half the pain points (and joys) players still argue about today, like corpse runs and brutal death penalties. Everything after owes it something.
About EverQuest
One of the foundational 3D MMORPGs, launched in 1999 and still running with regular expansions for its dedicated community.
- Released
- 1999
- Developer
- Sony Online Entertainment
EVE Online
Not really a fantasy MMO at all, it's a spreadsheet-powered space opera where player-run alliances fight wars that make the news. The learning cliff is real, but nothing else lets a single battle cost real-world thousands of dollars.
About EVE Online
A sandbox space MMO known for player-driven economy, large-scale fleet battles, and permadeath consequences for losing ships.
- Released
- 2003
- Developer
- CCP Games
The Elder Scrolls Online
Started shaky as a weird theme-park take on a sandbox franchise, then quietly became one of the most content-rich MMOs going, chapter after chapter. The one-tamriel overhaul fixed the leveling problem that doomed its early reputation.
About The Elder Scrolls Online
A multiplayer entry in Bethesda's Elder Scrolls series, set centuries before Skyrim. Known for its chapter-based expansion model and flexible class system.
- Released
- 2014
- Developer
- ZeniMax Online Studios
Albion Online
A full-loot sandbox that doesn't apologize for being brutal, with a player-driven economy where literally everything you wear was crafted by someone. It's niche, but the people who love it really love it.
About Albion Online
A cross-platform sandbox MMO with a full-loot economy where all gear is player-crafted.
- Released
- 2017
- Developer
- Sandbox Interactive
BB Tier: Solid, with a fanbase that knows exactly why
The Lord of the Rings Online
Walking through Moria or the Shire still hits for anyone who loves the books, and the music system remains a weirdly beloved feature. It's aged and the monetization got messy, but the zone design holds up.
About The Lord of the Rings Online
An MMO set in Tolkien's Middle-earth, following the story of the books and films through recreated locations like the Shire and Moria.
- Released
- 2007
- Developer
- Turbine
Star Wars: The Old Republic
Bioware poured a reported fortune into fully voiced class stories, and for the Jedi Knight or Sith Warrior arcs it was worth it. The endgame and later expansions never matched that opening strength, though.
About Star Wars: The Old Republic
A Star Wars MMO built around fully voiced class storylines, set thousands of years before the films.
- Released
- 2011
- Developer
- BioWare
Black Desert Online
Gorgeous character creator, combat that feels more action game than tab-target MMO, and a progression system so dense it needs third-party spreadsheets to parse. Beautiful, but the grind-to-content ratio wears people down.
About Black Desert Online
A Korean sandbox MMO known for its detailed character customization, action combat, and life skill systems.
- Released
- 2014
- Developer
- Pearl Abyss
Ragnarok Online
A huge deal in the early 2000s, especially across Southeast Asia and Brazil, with a job class system that let you become a Whitesmith or an Assassin and actually feel different. Private servers kept the community alive long after official support faded in the West.
About Ragnarok Online
A Korean MMO based on Norse-inspired manhwa art, especially popular in Southeast Asia and Latin America for its job class system.
- Released
- 2002
- Developer
- Gravity
MapleStory
Side-scrolling MMO that hooked a generation on 2D platforming combat and a cash shop that got infamous for how aggressive it became. Still running, still has diehards, still gets memed on for its gacha systems.
About MapleStory
A 2D side-scrolling MMORPG from Korea known for its platforming combat and long-running cash shop model.
- Released
- 2003
- Developer
- Nexon
Phantasy Star Online 2
Fast, stylish action combat that took forever to officially reach the West, and when it did arrive it came bundled with New Genesis, which split the playerbase's opinion on whether that was an upgrade.
About Phantasy Star Online 2
A fast-paced action MMO from Sega, released years earlier in Japan before finally launching in the West.
- Japan release
- 2012
- Western release
- 2020
Ultima Online
The granddaddy of the sandbox MMO, where full-loot PvP and player housing existed before most of the genre had even figured out combat. Rough by modern standards, but almost every sandbox idea traces back here.
About Ultima Online
One of the earliest major MMORPGs, launched in 1997 with a sandbox design built around housing, crafting, and open PvP.
- Released
- 1997
- Developer
- Origin Systems
Dungeons & Dragons Online
Took actual D&D rules and turned dungeons into real action-oriented instances instead of open-world filler. Underrated for how much it respects the source material, even if the hub city, Stormreach, never got the love it deserved.
About Dungeons & Dragons Online
An MMO adaptation of tabletop D&D rules, built around instanced dungeon design rather than a fully open world.
- Released
- 2006
- Developer
- Turbine
Lost Ark
Launched in the West to massive Steam numbers and gorgeous isometric action combat, then bled players fast once the endgame's gear-gated grind and bot problem became impossible to ignore. Still has a loyal core who'll defend the raid design to the end.
About Lost Ark
A Korean isometric action MMORPG published globally by Amazon Games, known for its dungeon raids and gear progression systems.
- Western release
- 2022
- Developer
- Smilegate RPG
CC Tier: Good ideas, rougher execution
Aion
Beautiful flight-combat gimmick and NCSoft production values couldn't save it from feeling like a generic theme park once the wings lost their novelty. Had a moment, then mostly faded outside dedicated regions.
About Aion
An NCSoft MMO notable for its flight-based combat system and conflict between angelic and demonic factions.
- Released
- 2008
- Developer
- NCSoft
Blade & Soul
Gorgeous martial-arts combat and a story mode that leaned hard into anime melodrama, but Western servers never shook the reputation for pay-to-win gear progression. The combat system deserved a better economy around it.
About Blade & Soul
A Korean martial arts fantasy MMO known for its fast combo-based combat and story-heavy presentation.
- Released
- 2012
- Developer
- NCSoft
Throne and Liberty
Amazon's second big MMO swing, with a day-night weather system and shapeshifting gimmick that looked great in trailers. Still too early to know if it avoids New World's fate, and early reception has been lukewarm at best.
About Throne and Liberty
A Korean MMO published by Amazon Games featuring dynamic weather, day-night cycles, and shapeshifting mechanics.
- Released
- 2024
- Developer
- NCSoft
New World
Launched to a massive player spike, then lost most of it within weeks as exploits, server queues, and balance patches piled up. Amazon kept patching it into something more respectable, but the damage to its reputation was already done.
About New World
Amazon Games' fantasy MMO set on a supernatural island, launched in 2021 with a notably rocky start.
- Released
- 2021
- Developer
- Amazon Games
FF Tier: Gone but not forgotten
Star Wars Galaxies
Beloved for its player-driven professions and genuinely unique sandbox systems, then gutted by the infamous Combat Upgrade and New Game Enhancements that alienated its own fanbase. Shut down in 2011, and still mourned harder than almost any MMO that's ever existed.
About Star Wars Galaxies
An early Star Wars sandbox MMO known for its player-driven professions and crafting economy before major system overhauls alienated its fanbase.
- Released
- 2003
- Shut down
- 2011
City of Heroes
Not bad, actually beloved, but shut down in 2012 by publisher decision rather than player abandonment, which still stings. Private server revivals keep the flame alive, proof the fanbase never actually left.
About City of Heroes
A superhero-themed MMO known for its character creator and mission architect system, shut down in 2012 and kept alive since by private servers.
- Released
- 2004
- Shut down
- 2012
How we ranked them
We weighed longevity, community size, how often each game gets brought up as a genre highlight, and how it's held up against newer competition. We leaned on what players and critics broadly agree on, server populations, Steam reviews, forum sentiment over the years, but we also made calls where the community is split down the middle. A game can rank high for history even if its current state is rough, and vice versa.
Think we got it wrong?
Drag all 23 mmorpgs into your own tier list, then download the image or share a link.
Rank these yourselfFAQ
What is the most popular MMORPG right now?
World of Warcraft and Final Fantasy XIV still draw the largest active communities, with Old School RuneScape close behind thanks to its huge, loyal player base.
What is considered the first true MMORPG?
Ultima Online (1997) is widely credited as the game that established the genre's core ideas, though Meridian 59 came slightly earlier and EverQuest later defined the 3D era.
Why did Star Wars Galaxies shut down?
LucasArts and Sony Online Entertainment ended the servers in 2011 after years of declining population, a decline many fans trace back to the controversial New Game Enhancements update in 2005.
Is New World worth playing now?
It's in a much better state than its rocky 2021 launch, with more content and better balance, but it still hasn't fully shaken its reputation among players who left early.
More rankings
Image credits
- World of WarcraftCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Final Fantasy XIVCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Old School RuneScapeLogo: Wikipedia · Source
- Guild Wars 2Cover: Wikipedia · Source
- EverQuestCover: Wikipedia · Source
- EVE OnlinePhoto: Unknown author, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons) · License · Source
- The Elder Scrolls OnlineCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Albion OnlineCover: Wikipedia · Source
- The Lord of the Rings OnlineCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Star Wars: The Old RepublicCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Black Desert OnlineLogo: Wikipedia · Source
- Ragnarok OnlinePhoto: http://iro.ragnarokonline.com/, Public domain (Wikimedia Commons) · Source
- MapleStoryPhoto: f0976531950157, Public domain (via Openverse) · Source
- Phantasy Star Online 2Logo: Wikipedia · Source
- Ultima OnlineCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Dungeons & Dragons OnlineCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Lost ArkCover: Wikipedia · Source
- AionCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Blade & SoulCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Throne and LibertyLogo: Wikipedia · Source
- New WorldCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Star Wars GalaxiesCover: Wikipedia · Source
- City of HeroesCover: Wikipedia · Source