Batman Movies Tier List: Every Film Ranked
Sixteen movies, one cape, and a wildly uneven history. We're covering the full range here, from Adam West's campy good time to Robert Pattinson's three-hour detective noir, with animated gems and some genuinely rough studio decisions mixed in.
This ranking leans on what fans and critics have hashed out for years across forums and reviews, with our own calls where the arguments never really settled. Think you'd swap a few spots? That's half the fun of a Batman list, everyone's got a take.
The tier list
The community’s tier list fills in as members vote. It appears once 5 members have ranked or voted on these.
Think you can rank them better?
Make your own tier listFree account. Your ranking stays private unless you share it, and it counts toward the community tier list.Vote
SS Tier: The best Batman has ever been
The Dark Knight
Heath Ledger's Joker turns a superhero sequel into a crime epic about chaos and order. The interrogation scene alone, with Batman losing his cool while Joker stays perfectly calm, is one of the best scenes the genre has ever produced.
About The Dark Knight
Nolan's sequel pitting Batman against Heath Ledger's Joker, widely considered one of the best superhero films ever made.
- Director
- Christopher Nolan
- Year
- 2008
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
An animated film that hits harder emotionally than most live-action ones, built around Bruce Wayne's first love and the cost of the mission he chose instead. Proof that DC's animated output has often outclassed the blockbusters.
About Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
An animated film tied to Batman: The Animated Series, exploring Bruce Wayne's past romance with Andrea Beaumont.
- Format
- Animated
- Year
- 1993
Batman (1989)
Tim Burton and Jack Nicholson basically invented the modern superhero movie template here. Gothic, weird, and still fun, with Danny Elfman's score doing half the heavy lifting.
About Batman (1989)
Tim Burton's gothic reinvention of the character, starring Michael Keaton as Batman and Jack Nicholson as the Joker.
- Director
- Tim Burton
- Year
- 1989
AA Tier: Excellent, no asterisks needed
The Batman
Matt Reeves goes full detective noir, and Robert Pattinson's Bruce Wayne is a hollowed-out recluse rather than a playboy. The Riddler's internet-troll menace and that extended car chase make it feel like nothing else in the franchise.
About The Batman
Matt Reeves' detective-focused take on the character, starring Robert Pattinson as an early-career Batman investigating the Riddler.
- Director
- Matt Reeves
- Year
- 2022
Batman Begins
Christopher Nolan's origin story takes Bruce's training seriously in a way no prior film bothered to. Liam Neeson's Ra's al Ghul and the Narrows sequence set up everything the trilogy would build on.
About Batman Begins
Christopher Nolan's franchise reboot, starring Christian Bale and tracing Bruce Wayne's training and early years as Batman.
- Director
- Christopher Nolan
- Year
- 2005
Batman: Under the Red Hood
A tight, brutal animated take on the Jason Todd story that doesn't flinch from the consequences of Batman's no-kill rule. Jensen Ackles' voice work as Red Hood sells the anger underneath the mask.
About Batman: Under the Red Hood
An animated adaptation dealing with the return of Jason Todd, the former Robin, as the vigilante Red Hood.
- Format
- Animated
- Year
- 2010
The Lego Batman Movie
Funnier and more insightful about the character than most of the serious films, poking at Bruce's loneliness while cramming in every villain Warner Bros. owns the rights to. Will Arnett's growl-bark delivery never gets old.
About The Lego Batman Movie
An animated comedy spin-off of The Lego Movie, with Will Arnett voicing a self-absorbed Batman.
- Format
- Animated
- Year
- 2017
BB Tier: Solid, with real flaws
Batman: The Killing Joke
The Joker material, adapted straight from Alan Moore's comic, is as sharp and disturbing as it should be. The extended Batgirl prologue bolted on the front remains the sticking point for a lot of fans, and it's a fair complaint.
About Batman: The Killing Joke
An animated adaptation of Alan Moore's acclaimed graphic novel exploring the Joker's possible origin.
- Format
- Animated
- Year
- 2016
Batman Returns
Burton leans even further into the gothic weirdness, and Michelle Pfeiffer's Catwoman is a genuine highlight. It trades Batman himself for villain spectacle a bit too often, which is why it sits just below the original.
About Batman Returns
Burton's darker, stranger sequel featuring Michelle Pfeiffer as Catwoman and Danny DeVito as the Penguin.
- Director
- Tim Burton
- Year
- 1992
The Dark Knight Rises
An ambitious, occasionally clunky close to Nolan's trilogy, with Tom Hardy's Bane giving it real physical menace. The plot asks a lot of favors from the audience, but the finale still lands.
About The Dark Knight Rises
The final film in Nolan's trilogy, featuring Tom Hardy as Bane and Anne Hathaway as Catwoman.
- Director
- Christopher Nolan
- Year
- 2012
Batman Ninja
Gonzo and visually inventive, tossing Batman and his rogues gallery into feudal Japan with a style unlike anything else on this list. It's a lot, in the best and occasionally most exhausting sense.
About Batman Ninja
An animated film that transports Batman and his rogues gallery to feudal Japan, blending anime style with the DC universe.
- Format
- Animated
- Year
- 2018
CC Tier: Fine, but uneven
Batman (1966)
Adam West's shark-repellent, pure camp era of Batman, and it knows exactly what it is. Judged as drama it's nothing, judged as a goofy good time it still mostly works.
About Batman (1966)
A feature film spin-off of the campy 1960s Batman TV series, starring Adam West and Burt Ward.
- Director
- Leslie H. Martinson
- Tone
- Camp comedy
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Ben Affleck is a genuinely good, world-weary Batman stuck in a bloated, self-serious script obsessed with mythology over character. The warehouse fight is great; the Martha moment is not.
About Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Zack Snyder's DCEU entry pitting Ben Affleck's Batman against Henry Cavill's Superman.
- Director
- Zack Snyder
- Year
- 2016
The Dark Knight Returns
A faithful animated adaptation of Frank Miller's landmark comic, split into two parts, that captures an aged, brutal Batman well even when the pacing drags in places.
About The Dark Knight Returns
A two-part animated adaptation of Frank Miller's influential comic about an aging Batman returning to action.
- Format
- Animated
DD Tier: Rough going
Batman Forever
Joel Schumacher's first swing at the franchise, with neon everywhere and Jim Carrey chewing scenery as the Riddler. Val Kilmer's Batman gets lost in the noise of a film that can't decide what tone it wants.
About Batman Forever
Joel Schumacher's first Batman film, starring Val Kilmer as Batman alongside Jim Carrey's Riddler and Tommy Lee Jones' Two-Face.
- Director
- Joel Schumacher
- Year
- 1995
FF Tier: The one everyone agrees on
Batman & Robin
Bat-nipples, ice puns, and a plot that exists mainly to sell toys. This is the film that killed the franchise for nearly a decade, and honestly, it earned that fate.
About Batman & Robin
Schumacher's follow-up, starring George Clooney as Batman, widely regarded as the low point of the franchise.
- Director
- Joel Schumacher
- Year
- 1997
How we ranked them
We weighed how each film holds up as a Batman story first: does it get the character and his world right? Then craftsmanship (direction, writing, performances), cultural impact, and simple rewatchability. Animated and live-action films were judged by the same standard: is it good Batman, full stop, not graded on a curve for being a cartoon or a tie-in.
Think we got it wrong?
Drag all 16 batman movies into your own tier list, then download the image or share a link.
Rank these yourselfFAQ
What is the best Batman movie of all time?
The Dark Knight tops most lists and ours, largely thanks to Heath Ledger's Joker, though Batman: Mask of the Phantasm and Tim Burton's 1989 Batman are right behind it for many fans.
What is the worst Batman movie?
Batman & Robin is the near-universal pick for worst, criticized for its campy tone, toy-driven design choices, and thin plot.
Is Batman Begins better than The Dark Knight?
Most critics and fans rank The Dark Knight higher, but Batman Begins is widely respected as the stronger origin story and sets up the trilogy's themes.
Are the animated Batman movies worth watching?
Yes. Films like Batman: Mask of the Phantasm and Batman: Under the Red Hood are frequently ranked above several live-action entries for their storytelling and voice performances.
Where does The Batman (2022) rank among Batman films?
It's generally placed near the top, just below the all-time classics, for its detective-driven take on the character and Robert Pattinson's performance.
More rankings
Image credits
- The Dark KnightCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman: Mask of the PhantasmCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman (1989)Cover: Wikipedia · Source
- The BatmanCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman BeginsCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman: Under the Red HoodCover: Wikipedia · Source
- The Lego Batman MovieCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman: The Killing JokeCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman ReturnsCover: Wikipedia · Source
- The Dark Knight RisesCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman NinjaCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman (1966)Cover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman v Superman: Dawn of JusticeCover: Wikipedia · Source
- The Dark Knight ReturnsCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman ForeverCover: Wikipedia · Source
- Batman & RobinCover: Wikipedia · Source